Hungarian-Jewish filmmaker László Nemes has returned with its first film in seven years and – it’s no coincidence – his third consecutive movie Set up or around war hours. Given the neorealist ”Orphan“Is based on his father’s own upbringing in Budapest after the war, it is easy to see why World Chaos and its impact on everyday life has become something of a fixation for him.
Its performance is a good looking for one film – And Absolutely credible for a family story From Anarchic Eastern Europe after World War II. A boy grew up with fables by a long lost father who was assumed to have fallen victim to the Nazi camp. The young Andor (Bojtorján Barabas) still gets stuck because he can return, despite the best efforts from his mother Klara (Andrea Waskovics) to convince him that 12 years would certainly be long enough for him to have returned to Budapest for sure and good.
Instead, a burly butcher named Mihály (Grégory Gadebois) dives at their door and claims to be Andor’s father. Mihály’s arrival – or return – urges an existential crisis for Andor. Mihály is a brute who abuses his mother. And he kills pigs to support himself. For Andor, this is a personal and ethnic disaster, which gives unwelcome questions about who he got up to. Mihály lives in the countryside, rides on a motorcycle, drinks heavy and prefers boxing for football. Even in an era where red flags are sacred, everything appears that exaggerated. Andor runs away to the synagogue his family had participated before the war, but finds no fulfillment there either.
More pressing than Andor’s personal crisis is the political a engrossing Hungary. The Soviets have laid down a rebellion against the Puppet Government that ruled in Budapest and is now removing politicians, students and generals who had led it. One of those who is still hiding underground is the older brother of Andor’s best friend Sàri (Elíz Szabó). In the middle of the chaos and fear, Andor has no room to explore his bubbling insecurities. They risk overflowing and threaten more than just family safety.
Andor’s teenage novel with Sàri is a silver lining in a dark place. They roam the streets together and go up to general damage. Andor is cheeky and has charisma, which deserves him to Sàri. More important than his rizz, however, is a gun that he picked up somewhere on the road. Andor participates in customs in Sàri’s house, where her grandfather reminds them: “The adults and the children fled to Egypt. But only the children entered the promised country.”
Neme’s assessment of the feeling-that these children would inherit a promised country in Eastern Europe after the war-is not optimistic. Although “Orphan” has a soft Sepia -Glint (and on the 35 mm film it is managed on, it sings), this is far from nostalgia. The subtitle to “Orphan” seems to be that Eastern Europe Jews must survive the order of the post-war by going to bed-mixed literally-with some unusual, unpleasant characters. Klara’s Pragmatism Diillusions Andor, but she is an adult: without any belief in an upcoming promised country, what else is there?
The depiction of the social anarchy that is in once large cities in Europe after the war for decades after it ended is distinct and effective. Nemes is clearly influenced by the greats in this area. Andors escapades have shades of “bicycle thieves.” More directly, “Orphan” seems to be affected by Roberto Rossellini’s undervalued “Germany, year zero”, about another lonely fair -haired boy, filmed in the wastewar in the post -war period. It helps that Barabas like Andor has the face on a neo-realistic hero and Gadebois’s face on a neo-realistic villain. In fact, Gadebois can be a rather convincing villain in any genre and any era.
“Orphan” is not a low budget film in any way, but its filmmaking is minimalist. Nemes, which he always has, enjoys trickery, choreography and blockage rather than large sets. When Andor and Sàri Sprint through the lively streets in Budapest former stores and trucks, a wooden plank is missing from a vehicle at the exact height so we can see their faces. In another scene, a wooden cut where people can pose as pilots in an airplane are carried past Klara and Mihály, who inadvertently show up in the-but there is no room on board for Andor.
Neme’s understanding of the film methods in the time when his film is based puts “Orphan” from other, more conventional historical drama. As with “Son of Saul” and “Sunset”, this is a sophisticated endeavor and, in craftsmanship, a level above the norm. Credit to cinematographer and long Nemes collaborative partner Mátyás Erdély for taking a movie that doesn’t look like anything else on Venice This year. It doesn’t sound much else either. The Russian composers Evgueni and Sacha Galperine choose an old-fashioned swelling point that sits well with the 30 pop songs that are often seen listening to.
But it’s not all fun and games: When Sirens quarrels in Budapest, they continue as long notes even after the police have gone. Even in moments of relative calm, alarms are just ever around the corner.
Rating: B+
“Orphan” premiered at 2025 Venice Film Festival. It is currently seeking US distribution.
Want to keep you updated on IndieWire’s movie Reviews And critical thoughts? Subscribe here To our recently launched newsletter, in review by David Ehrlich, where our main film critic and Head Review’s editor rounds off the best new reviews and streaming choices along with some exclusive Musings – all only available for subscribers.
